Bo Bichette has returned to form in a big way this season, and his franchise-record-setting hit streak in recent games has reminded the Toronto Blue Jays of a fast-approaching decision.

Bichette set a Blue Jays record over a two-game span, registering hits in nine consecutive at-bats against the Detroit Tigers on Sunday and Baltimore Orioles on Monday.

The streak broke the record of eight, previously jointly held by Rance Mulliniks, Paul Molitor, Tony Fernandez and Adam Lind.

Most hits in consecutive at-bats, Blue Jays history

Player Season Consecutive hits
Bo Bichette  2025  9 
Adam Lind  2009  8 
Tony Fernandez  1999  8 
Paul Molitor  1995  8 
Rance Mulliniks  1984  8 

The recent surge, where Bichette has gone 19-for-45 on a 10-game hitting streak entering Tuesday's action, has spiked his batting average from .280 to .295.

He's also jumped to the top of the hits list across the majors, surpassing injured New York Yankees slugger Aaron Judge.

MLB hits leaders entering Tuesday

Player Team Hits
Bo Bichette  Toronto Blue Jays  130 
Aaron Judge  New York Yankees  129 
Trea Turner  Philadelphia Phillies  125 
Manny Machado  San Diego Padres  124 
Jackson Chourio  Milwaukee Brewers  121 

This level of production is what the team has come to expect of Bichette, who has led the AL in hits twice in his career, is a career .291 hitter and a two-time All-Star.

It has also led to some difficult conversations within the organization, after Bichette's longtime teammate Vladimir Guerrero Jr. was awarded a 14-year, $500 million extension in April while Bichette is playing out the final year of his contract.

At just 27 years old and with three seasons that garnered MVP votes under his belt, a potential long-term contract for the Blue Jays shortstop has been difficult for both sides to come to an agreement on - especially given Bichette's struggles in 2024, where he hit .225 in 81 games while missing time with multiple injuries.

"When he hits free agency, he's going to be one of the most interesting free agents in years," MLB.com's Keegan Matheson said in an appearance on OverDrive on TSN1050 on Monday.

"Some teams will think he's a shortstop, and is going to hit forever. Some teams will look at him and say 'Woah, you're really slowing down, you're a second baseman, we don't know about the bat.' There's going to be a really big range."

Bichette's defence at shortstop has been inconsistent throughout his career - per Statcast, he's ranked below league average in fielding value in four of six full seasons.

But there's no doubting the value of a player who can consistently hit for a high average and provide power on occasion.

"Every time I've talked to him, he's said the same thing, that he loves it [in Toronto] and that he wants to be [in Toronto]," Matheson said.

Bichette's play has helped guide the Blue Jays (63-44) atop the American League East, as they own a comfortable 5.5-game lead over the New York Yankees in the division. The focus now is on claiming the team's first AL East division title since 2015, and the contract discussion will follow afterwards.